Skip to Content

Worried about candidates using AI? See our AI-resistant tests.

Why soft skills might be the most important thing you hire for

Written by
Joshua Hancock
Updated

We've all made that hire: impressive CV, perfect experience, but they struggled to fit in or perform. More often than not, the missing piece is soft skills.

Soft skills decide whether someone's technical ability actually translates into results at work.

What are soft skills?

Soft skills are the interpersonal and personal attributes that determine how effectively people interact with others, manage themselves, and navigate workplace challenges. Unlike hard skills that are job-specific (technical abilities like coding or accounting), soft skills are transferable across all roles and industries.

Some examples of important soft skills:

  1. Communication - expressing ideas clearly and listening actively.
  2. Teamwork - collaborating effectively and building trust.
  3. Adaptability - thriving in changing environments.
  4. Learning agility - a drive to seek out, absorb, and apply new knowledge.
  5. Emotional intelligence - understanding and managing emotions.
  6. Resilience - maintaining performance under pressure.
  7. Leadership - motivating and influencing others.

It's worth separating soft skills from cognitive ability. Problem-solving, critical thinking, and how quickly someone picks things up are often lumped in with soft skills, but they're really cognitive ability, the strongest single predictor of job performance, and best measured with ability tests. Soft skills sit alongside that, shaping how someone uses their ability day to day.

Are soft skills more important than hard skills?

It depends on the role, but soft skills are often what separates the hires who succeed from those who don't. Decades of research show that personality traits like conscientiousness reliably predict job performance across almost every type of role (Barrick & Mount, 1991).

This doesn't mean hard skills are irrelevant. When hiring a developer, you will need to hire someone who knows how to code. But two developers with the same technical skills can perform very differently once they're in the team, and that difference usually comes down to how they communicate, take feedback, handle pressure, and work with others.

Can soft skills be developed?

Some soft skills, like communication or giving feedback, can be improved with coaching and practice. But the parts rooted in personality, like resilience, emotional stability, or a natural drive to learn, shift much less over time.

That's why it's usually better to hire for soft skills than to hope you can train them in later. Training can sharpen what's already there, but it rarely builds it from scratch.

Soft skills have a real impact on workplace and team performance

The impact of soft skills shows up in almost every part of how a team works. Hire people with strong soft skills and you tend to get:

  • Better collaboration - disagreements get resolved rather than festering, and projects keep moving.
  • Happier customers - empathy, patience, and active listening turn routine interactions into repeat business.
  • Smoother change - resilient, adaptable people bounce back from setbacks and help others adjust.
  • Informal leaders - people who step up, influence, and motivate others, whatever their job title.
  • Better wellbeing and retention - emotionally stable teams handle pressure without burning out, and people stay.

None of these show up on a CV, which is exactly why they're so easy to overlook when hiring.

The case study of Southwest Airlines

Southwest Airlines built their entire hiring strategy around founder Herb Kelleher's philosophy: "Hire for attitude, train for skill." But what does this look like in practice?

According to Julie Weber, Southwest's then VP of People, they don't hire for generic "soft skills." Instead, they target three specific attributes:

  1. Warrior spirit - the desire to excel, act with courage, and persevere.
  2. Servant's heart - putting others first and treating everyone with respect.
  3. Fun-loving attitude - passion, joy, and not taking yourself too seriously.

Southwest Airlines use behavioural interview questions to assess these traits. When faced with two equally qualified candidates, the one with Southwest's values gets the offer. More importantly, they won't hire qualified candidates who lack these attributes.

Why does this matter? Southwest became one of the most consistently successful airlines in US history, profitable for 47 consecutive years before the pandemic, and consistently among the major US airlines with the fewest customer complaints.

Soft skills matter most when hiring graduates and young employees

When hiring graduates and young employees, soft skills become even more critical.

A recent graduate's technical skills will inevitably be limited. They haven't had years to master specific software, or develop deep expertise in their field. But their soft skills? Those are already well established.

You can teach a graduate your systems, processes, and technical skills within months. But you can't easily teach them to be naturally collaborative, resilient, or emotionally intelligent. Those traits will shape their long-term success and growth potential.

Instead of focusing on degrees, past experience and technical knowledge (which are fairly poor measures of job performance for young graduates), prioritise candidates who demonstrate some of the most essential soft skills:

  1. Communication skills - expressing ideas clearly in presentations, writing, and interpersonal interactions
  2. Learning agility - a drive to seek out new knowledge, take on feedback, and keep developing
  3. Resilience and adaptability - bouncing back from setbacks and thriving in changing environments
  4. Natural collaboration - working effectively in teams through projects, sports, or group activities
  5. Emotional intelligence - reading social situations, managing emotions, and building relationships

Pair these with an ability test, and you've covered the two things that matter most in a graduate: how quickly they can learn, and how they'll work once they're in the team. This approach is particularly valuable for graduate schemes and early careers programmes, where you're investing in someone's long-term potential rather than immediate technical contribution.

“The best long-term hires often aren't those with the highest grades, but those with the strongest interpersonal skills and growth mindset.”

Ignoring soft skills can have a negative effect on productivity, profitability and retention

Overlooking soft skills doesn't just mean missing out; it actively harms performance. And the costs compound.

Poor soft skills in just one of your employees can create a domino effect that damages entire teams:

Effects of poor soft skills

  • Poor communication → misunderstandings, rework, and project delays
  • Lack of teamwork → silos, internal conflict, and duplicated effort
  • Low emotional intelligence → poor customer interactions and damaged relationships
  • Poor adaptability → resistance to change and missed opportunities
  • Weak leadership → low morale, high turnover, and lost productivity

The research backs this up. Leadership IQ's well-known study of new hires found that when they failed, it was for attitudinal reasons 89% of the time - things like coachability, emotional intelligence, motivation, and temperament - and for a lack of technical skill only 11% of the time.

A technically strong hire with weak soft skills can end up costing a team more than they contribute. Soft skills aren't simply "nice-to-haves". They have a direct effect on productivity, profitability, and retention.

Remote work and AI have made soft skills even more important

Remote and hybrid work

Without face-to-face interaction, employees need stronger self-motivation, clearer communication, and better self-discipline. Remote work exposes soft skills gaps that might stay hidden in an office: someone who lacks self-motivation, or won't ask for help when they need it, can become extremely unproductive when left to work independently.

Those lacking in communication and teamwork skills are also more likely to work in silos and not reach out when they need to.

Automation and AI

AI tools like ChatGPT have dramatically reduced the importance of many technical skills. Non-coders can now build apps, and Excel novices can perform complex analyses with AI assistance.

As AI handles more routine technical work, what's left for people is increasingly the work AI can't do well: building relationships, persuading, leading, and making judgement calls with and about other people.

The most valuable employees now combine cognitive ability and strong soft skills with the ability to use AI tools well. As AI becomes more embedded in everyday work, that combination is only going to become more valuable.

Conclusion and next steps

Soft skills aren't a secondary consideration in hiring. Alongside cognitive ability, they're often what decides whether a hire succeeds.

Knowing soft skills are important is one thing, but knowing which of your candidates have the right ones is another.

There are several ways to assess soft skills, from structured and unstructured interviews to personality assessments. From working with hundreds of hiring teams, we've found the best approach combines two: behavioural assessments early in the process, then structured interviews to explore the results. We explain how and why in our guide to how to assess soft skills in your candidates.

Josh Hancock
Primary author

Joshua Hancock

Head of Digital Marketing at Test Partnership. Over seven years' experience as a writer, content strategist, SEO and digital marketer.